$5 OFF $50 + FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $44.99+

Skip to product information
Nostalgic Peanut Butter Cup Childhood Coffee

Peanut Butter Cup Coffee That Tastes Like Your Favorite Childhood Candy

Creamy peanut butter and rich chocolate in every cup — the indulgent combo you never knew your mornings needed.

$18.99
Sale price  $18.99 Regular price 
Free shipping at $44.99 • Save $5 when you spend $50+
Reg/Decaf
Coffee Grind
Bag Size

Chocolate Meets Peanut Butter — In the Best Cup of Your Morning

Rich, creamy, and dangerously good — that iconic moment when chocolate meets peanut butter, now in a coffee you’ll reach for every single day.

Peanut Butter Cup Coffee is the one that becomes your new obsession. Creamy peanut butter and milk chocolate over a smooth Arabica base — indulgent, comforting, and impossible to have just one cup of. Small-batch roasted to order.


☕ Flavor Profile

  • Creamy Peanut Butter — rich, smooth, deeply satisfying
  • Milk Chocolate — sweet, velvety, perfectly balanced
  • Smooth Arabica Base — medium roast, never harsh

✨ What Makes It Different

  • 🫘 Small-batch roasted to order — peak freshness in every bag
  • 🚫 No artificial aftertaste — just clean peanut butter-chocolate flavor
  • ⚙️ Choose your grind: Whole Bean, Drip Grind, or French Press

🎁 Perfect For

  • Morning treats that feel like dessert before noon
  • Gifting to the peanut butter cup fan in your life
  • Anyone who loves Reese’s and wishes they could drink one

Pairs beautifully with: Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies or Peanut Butter Cookies 🍪


📦 Our Promise

  • Ships in 1–2 days
  • Free shipping on orders $44.99+
  • 30-day satisfaction guarantee — love it or we make it right

Small-batch. Roasted to order. Your new morning obsession.

🔒 Secure Checkout
🛡️ 30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
🚚 Free Shipping $44.99+

✓ Love it or your money back — 30 days to try your new favorite coffee and treats.

Small-batch crafted, big on flavor — premium coffees, teas, and gourmet treats worth savoring.

Sourced with intention. Sealed for freshness. Delivered to your door ready to enjoy.

Where every sip and every bite is a moment worth savoring — crafted for the discerning palate.

Free shipping on orders $44.99+ — because exceptional treats deserve a seamless journey to your door.

You May Also Like

Almond Cookies That Are Toasty, Nutty & Impossible to Eat Just One

Almond Cookies That Are Toasty, Nutty & Impossible to Eat Just One

Almond Cookies That Are Toasty, Nutty & Impossible to Eat Just One

Real butter and premium toasted almonds in every bite — fresh-baked to order, never frozen, never sitting on a shelf.

$19.99
Sale price  $19.99 Regular price 
Free shipping at $44.99 • Save $5 when you spend $50+
Almond Toffee Coffee That Tastes Like Your Favorite Candy Shop

Almond Toffee Coffee That Tastes Like Your Favorite Candy Shop

Almond Toffee Coffee That Tastes Like Your Favorite Candy Shop

Toasted almond and buttery toffee flavor — the nutty, sweet cup you can't get from any grocery store brand.

$18.99
Sale price  $18.99 Regular price 
Free shipping at $44.99 • Save $5 when you spend $50+
Amaretto Coffee That Tastes Like Italian Indulgence in Every Sip

Amaretto Coffee That Tastes Like Italian Indulgence in Every Sip

Amaretto Coffee That Tastes Like Italian Indulgence in Every Sip

Sweet almond and amaretto flavor — the sophisticated cup that makes every morning feel like a treat.

$18.99
Sale price  $18.99 Regular price 
Free shipping at $44.99 • Save $5 when you spend $50+
Birthday Cake Coffee That Makes Every Morning Feel Like a Celebration

Birthday Cake Coffee That Makes Every Morning Feel Like a Celebration

Birthday Cake Coffee That Makes Every Morning Feel Like a Celebration

Sweet vanilla cake and buttery frosting flavor — celebrate every morning, no occasion needed.

$18.99
Sale price  $18.99 Regular price 
Free shipping at $44.99 • Save $5 when you spend $50+