Skip to product information
Peanut Butter Cookies
Real butter and generous peanut butter in every bite — the classic that never disappoints, fresh-baked to order, never frozen.
$36.99
Shipping calculated at checkout.
🚚 Free shipping on orders $44.99+
✅ Freshly baked after your order. Never frozen. Ships in 1–2 business days.
Pairs beautifully with: Peanut Butter Cup Coffee, Caramel Coffee, or Highlander Grogg Coffee ☕
Rich, Nutty, and Perfectly Soft — The Peanut Butter Cookie That Sets the Standard
Deep peanut butter flavor, soft and tender texture, and that satisfying denseness that makes every bite feel indulgent. The peanut butter cookie done exactly right.
Small-batch baked to order from real ingredients — never mass-produced, never frozen.
Flavor Profile
🥜 Rich Peanut Butter Deep & nutty | 🌰 Warm Nuttiness Toasty & comforting | ✨ Subtle Sweetness Perfectly balanced |
What Makes Them Different
- 🧑🍳 Small-batch baked to order — real ingredients, never mass-produced
- ❄️ Never frozen — fresh-baked quality in every box
- 🍪 Soft and dense — melt-in-your-mouth peanut butter perfection
Not Sure Which Size to Choose?
- Half Dozen (6) — Great for sampling or a personal treat. Available on select cookies.
- 1 Dozen (12) — Perfect for treating yourself, sharing, or gifting.
- 2 Dozen (24) — Best for gatherings, larger gifts, or keeping extra cookies on hand.
Our Promise
- Ships in 1–2 days
- Free shipping on orders $44.99+
- 30-day satisfaction guarantee — love them or we make it right
🔒
Secure Checkout
🛡️
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
🚚
Free Shipping $44.99+